The Indianapolis Colts are facing a difficult decision regarding the future of their legendary kicker Adam Vinatieri.

The 46 year old continues to endure an up-and-down season in Indianapolis, where every time it appears he has safely turned the corner, his struggles once again rear their ugly head—raising questions of whether this is truly the end.

It came again at the worst possible time on Sunday, as Vinatieri badly missed a game-winning 43-yard field goal attempt wide left that would’ve sent the Colts home with an impressive road victory.